Quick Comparison

Magnesium GlycinateMelatonin
Half-Life12-17 hours40-60 minutes
Typical DosageStandard: 200-400 mg elemental magnesium daily (note: magnesium glycinate is ~14% elemental magnesium by weight, so 2000 mg magnesium glycinate provides ~280 mg elemental). Take in the evening for sleep benefits. Can be split into 2 doses.Optimal sleep dose: 0.3-1 mg taken 30-60 minutes before bed. Commercial doses of 3-10 mg are higher than needed and can cause next-day grogginess. Extended-release forms help with sleep maintenance (waking in the middle of the night).
AdministrationOral (capsules, powder, tablets). Well-tolerated. Take with or without food.Oral (tablets, capsules, gummies, sublingual). Sublingual provides faster onset.
Research Papers8 papers10 papers
Categories

Mechanism of Action

Magnesium Glycinate

Magnesium is required for over 300 enzymatic reactions including neurotransmitter synthesis (tyrosine hydroxylase, tryptophan hydroxylase), energy production (ATPases, kinases, glycolytic enzymes), and DNA repair (PARP, DNA polymerases). In the brain, magnesium blocks NMDA receptors at the voltage-dependent Mg2+ binding site within the channel pore (GluN1/GluN2 subunits), preventing excessive calcium influx and excitotoxicity — Mg2+ is displaced only upon depolarization and glycine/glutamate binding. The glycine component activates inhibitory glycine receptors (GlyR alpha1/alpha2) in the brainstem and spinal cord, and serves as an obligatory co-agonist at the GluN1 glycine site of NMDA receptors. Glycine also modulates NMDA receptor function. Together, magnesium and glycine produce calming effects through complementary inhibitory mechanisms: reduced glutamatergic excitability and enhanced inhibitory neurotransmission.

Melatonin

Melatonin binds to G-protein-coupled MT1 and MT2 receptors, which are densely expressed in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) of the hypothalamus—the brain's master circadian pacemaker. MT1 activation couples to Gi/o proteins, inhibiting adenylyl cyclase and reducing cAMP, which suppresses SCN neuronal firing and promotes sleepiness. MT2 activation modulates cGMP signaling and phase-shifts the circadian rhythm (useful for jet lag and shift work). Melatonin also has direct antioxidant properties, scavenging hydroxyl and peroxyl radicals in mitochondria and upregulating antioxidant enzymes like glutathione peroxidase. It supports immune function through modulation of T-cell cytokine production and may act at MT3 (quinone reductase 2) binding sites. Low doses are often more effective because they mimic physiological nighttime levels.

Risks & Safety

Magnesium Glycinate

Common

Mild drowsiness (often desired), loose stools at high doses (less than with other forms).

Serious

Avoid high doses with kidney impairment.

Rare

Diarrhea, nausea.

Melatonin

Common

Morning grogginess (especially at high doses), vivid dreams, mild headache.

Serious

May worsen symptoms in people with autoimmune conditions. Interacts with blood thinners, diabetes medications, and immunosuppressants.

Rare

Depression, daytime sleepiness, reduced sex drive with chronic high-dose use.

Full Profiles